MyFlightbook supports both of these scenarios, using two different paradigms.
- In the first paradigm, the student and the instructor create a relationship between their accounts, so one appears as the instructor for the other. Because each account is authenticated to MyFlightbook, and MyFlightbook validates the relationship, I refer to this as an "Authenticated" scenario. This provides a very secure framework for signed flights and endorsements, but it requires that both parties use MyFlightbook.
- In the second paradigm, the relationship is a one-off; there is no presumption of any ongoing relationship between the instructor and the student (a common example might be a check-out at an FBO). This provides more limited functionality, but is very quick to set up. I refer to this as the "Ad-hoc" scenario. Because there is no authentication of the instructor in an ad-hoc relationship, this must be done face-to-face.
EndorsementsAn endorsement is a sign-off from an instructor that determines the student hes met some criteria. The key thing about an endorsement is that it is not tied to a specific flight. Examples of endorsements include solo sign off, high-altitude training, tailwheel sign-off, readiness for a practical test, etc.
A wide variety of templates for common endorsements are in the system, as well as a template for a fully-customized endorsement.
Endorsements require an authenticated relationship between the student and the instructor. The endorsement can be issued by the instructor by going to the list of their students; they can also view any previously-issued endorsements.
An endorsement, once issued, cannot be edited or deleted. (After all, neither scenario is generally supported in the physical paper world), although as site admin I can, if needed, wade in and perform endorsement surgery as needed. Endorsements also cannot be dated too far in the past or in the future, as a security measure.
SignaturesMost training flights result in the instructor signing the student's logbook entry for the flight. Often, they even fill out the entry. But one difference between MyFlightbook and a paper logbook is that saving the entry and signing it are separate sequential steps. The reason for this is so that the signature can sign the flight as it exists in the database, without the possibility of modifying it between signing and saving.
If the instructor wishes to fill in the entry, they can do so. But just as they can't fill in a student's logbook without the student being there to give it to them, the student must be present with their phone/tablet (or sign in on a website) and hand control over to the instructor. For security, MyFlightbook does not allow instructors to create arbitrary new entries into a student's logbook.
There are two basic scenarios for how a flight can be signed once it has been saved:
- In-person. This requires a phone/tablet running the MyFlightbook app. The student goes to the Recent Flights list, finds the flight to be signed (typically at the top of the list, if you're signing the flight you just took), and chooses the "Sign" option. At this point, choose from a list of authenticated instructors or select a new instructor for ad-hoc signing, and then hand their phone/tablet to the instructor. If it's an authenticated relationship, the instructor provides their password to prove it's them and thus digitally sign the flight; if it's ad-hoc, they can scribble a signature with their finger (which is why it requires a phone/tablet), which serves as the signature. In either case, the instructors can add comments and, if authenticated, the instructor can cause the signed flight to be copied to their account (minus the signature and with Dual/CFI roles reversed).
- Remotely. This requires use of the website, and requires an authenticated relationship. The student can request that the instructor sign specific flights. The instructor will receive an email notifying them of the flights to sign, and can use the website to review and sign them. Or, the student can optionally grant the instructor permission to view their logbook and sign any flights that don't already have a valid signature, as they see fit.
Does the FAA recognize such digital signatures? They claim to, and they outline the criteria for doing so in FAA circular AC No: 120-78A. I believe MyFlightbook is compliant with this AC, the FAA has thus far not indicated willingness to even evaluate, much less certify, online logbook systems for compliance.
A more in depth explanation of how signatures and endorsements work, along with why I believe MyFlightbook is compliant with AC 120-78A can be found here.